When the European Union wrote the Digital Services Act, it built a ladder of obligations that climbed with the size of the platform. The smallest intermediary had to post basic contact details and act on notices. The largest, designated Very Large Online Platforms, had to map systemic risks across their entire catalogues and then prove that the measures they took actually reduced those risks. The rulebook entered into force in August 2023, and its strictest tier was reserved for services that reached more than 45 million monthly active users inside the bloc, roughly ten percent of the EU population.
Temu crossed that line and was designated a Very Large Online Platform on 31 May 2024 after declaring more than 45 million monthly active users in the EU. By September 2024 the company had declared 92 million monthly users, and Commission officials now put its EU user base above 120 million. The marketplace, owned by PDD Holdings, connects European shoppers directly to a vast network of third-country sellers, most of them small merchants listing toys, electronics, cosmetics, clothing and household goods at prices that undercut conventional retail. That structure is precisely the one the DSA was designed to interrogate: a platform that does not own the inventory it sells but does control who may list, how listings are ranked, and what happens when a product turns out to be dangerous.
The Commission opened formal proceedings against Temu in October 2024. The investigation was never limited to product safety. It covered the sale of illegal products, addictive design, recommender systems and researcher access to platform data, four separate strands under one case file. The first strand to reach a decision was risk assessment. In May 2026 the Commission fined Temu EUR 200 million, or USD 220.12 million, on the grounds that the company had not carried out appropriate risk assessments, having allowed the sale of illegal products such as dangerous baby toys and faulty chargers. Reuters reported on 17 November 2026 that this was the first penalty imposed on Temu in the investigation, and that the Commission then asked the company to produce an action plan to cure the breach.
Temu duly submitted that plan, and in October 2026 the Commission approved it. That approval was not the end of the story. The Commission's reading of the file was that an accepted remediation plan addresses the specific deficiency that triggered the earlier fine, namely the failure to assess risk properly, but it does not by itself settle whether the measures a platform actually operates are reasonable, proportionate and effective. That second question is the subject of the findings published in Brussels on 17 November 2026, and it is the question on which Temu now finds itself exposed to a far larger penalty.
Key Facts
The European Commission issued preliminary findings on 17 November 2026 that Temu breached Article 35 of the Digital Services Act, the provision that obliges Very Large Online Platforms to put in place reasonable, proportionate and effective measures to mitigate systemic risks. The press release, numbered IP/26/2463 and dated Brussels, 17 November 2026, identifies three problem areas rather than one. Euronews reported on 17 November 2026, in a story by Jonathan Benton published at 13:00 GMT plus one, that the Commission accused Temu of not doing enough to stop illegal and unsafe products from being sold, in preliminary findings that could see the Chinese online marketplace fined up to 6 percent of its global annual turnover.
The first problem area is product safety control. According to the Commission, Temu requires sellers to provide test reports for only a very small share of products, and even where reports are supplied they are often not checked. The company does flag high-risk categories, including toys, electronics and cosmetics, but does not prioritise those categories in physical checks. Spot-check results have often not been followed up, and inspections have not increased despite growth in the number of listings on the platform. The second problem area is content moderation. The Commission found that Temu's moderation system looks mainly at listing information and at compliance with Temu's own terms of service rather than at the safety of the product itself, that its matching against previously identified non-compliant listings does not focus enough on unsafe-product risk, and that the number of human moderators has not grown in step with the catalogue.
The third problem area is sanctions. The Commission describes Temu's sanction system as fragmented and ineffective because penalties land on individual stores rather than on the trader operating behind them. A trader whose store is closed can therefore keep selling through other stores, and traders are able to commit many serious infringements, including selling products that fail safety checks, before any store is suspended. Reuters reported on 17 November 2026, in a story from Brussels by Inti Landauro and Foo Yun Chee, that the Commission said Temu's mitigation measures include ineffective controls to check the compliance of products, a weak content moderation system and an ineffective sanction system.
The procedural consequences are spelled out in the same documents. Temu may examine the file and reply in writing, and the European Board for Digital Services is being consulted in parallel. If the findings are confirmed, the Commission may adopt a non-compliance decision that would trigger a fine of up to 6 percent of the provider's total worldwide annual turnover, plus an order to remedy the breach. A Temu spokesperson told Reuters that the company disagreed with the preliminary findings, that it makes significant efforts to mitigate illegal product risk, and that it will respond to the Commission. "We are confident that we will reach an amicable resolution of the matter that fully addresses the Commission's remaining concerns," the spokesperson said.
Consumer groups welcomed the move. EUobserver reported on 17 November 2026, in a Brussels dispatch by Fred Byrne timed at 12:29, that Agustin Reyna, director general of the consumer protection body BEUC, said the organisation was happy to see the Commission take consumer organisations' complaints and evidence seriously regarding how Temu fails to meet its obligations, adding that consumers should be able to shop safely on very large online marketplaces. The same report notes that the probe into Temu's compliance with EU law was launched in 2024 and that the DSA has been in force since August 2023.
Analysis
The legal architecture of this case explains why Brussels has now moved twice against the same company on what looks at first like the same subject. Article 34 and Article 35 of the DSA form a pair. Article 34 requires a platform to identify and assess systemic risks, and Article 35 requires it to mitigate them with measures that are reasonable, proportionate and effective. The May 2026 fine concerned the assessment limb. The November findings concern the mitigation limb. From the Commission's standpoint the sequence is not duplication but completion: a platform can produce a thorough risk assessment and still fail the legal test if the machinery it operates afterwards does not actually reduce the risk it identified. That is the theory of harm written into the 17 November file, and it is why the accepted action plan from October 2026 did not close the matter.
Read closely, each of the three findings attacks a different failure mode, and together they describe a compliance system that is documentary rather than operational. On safety, the Commission is not saying that Temu has no controls at all; it is saying that the controls are narrow in coverage, unprioritised in targeting and unclosed in follow-up. Test reports for a very small share of products, unchecked when submitted, are a paper trail rather than a filter. Flagging toys, electronics and cosmetics as high-risk while declining to prioritise them in physical inspections is an acknowledgement of risk without a matching allocation of enforcement effort. On moderation, judging a listing by its own description and by the platform's terms is a textual exercise, and a textual exercise cannot determine whether a charger will electrocute its user. On sanctions, punishing stores rather than traders converts a compliance penalty into a cost of doing business, because the entity that absorbs the penalty is disposable and the entity that controls it is not.
What this really means is that the Commission has shifted its theory of Temu's non-compliance from ignorance to inaction. The May fine said, in effect, that Temu had not looked hard enough at the risks its marketplace created. The November findings say that Temu looked, or was on notice, and did not build the operational machinery to act on what it saw. That is a more serious characterisation for a platform, because it is harder to cure with a document and easier to convert into a structural remedy order. It also explains the change in financial exposure. The earlier penalty was a fixed EUR 200 million. The ceiling now cited is 6 percent of total worldwide annual turnover, a formula that scales with the size of the business and is designed to be felt by a company of PDD Holdings' dimensions.
The bigger picture here is that the DSA's mitigation standard is turning into the real battleground for large marketplaces, and the outcome will be read well beyond Brussels. Very Large Online Platforms have spent the past three years building transparency reports, risk registers and compliance teams. The Temu file tests whether those artefacts are enough. If the Commission confirms its findings, the operative question for every marketplace with third-country sellers will be how much physical verification, human moderation and trader-level identity enforcement it must fund, and whether store-level sanctions can ever satisfy a standard that requires measures to be effective rather than merely available. Temu's defence, that it makes significant efforts, will succeed only if effort is measured by effect.
Why It Matters
The immediate stake is money. A fine of up to 6 percent of worldwide annual turnover is the sharpest instrument in the DSA's enforcement box, and it arrives on top of the EUR 200 million already paid in May 2026. But the larger stake is structural. A non-compliance decision can be paired with an order to remedy the breach, which in practice means the Commission could demand changes to how Temu onboards sellers, verifies test documentation, prioritises inspections and structures penalties. For a marketplace whose commercial logic rests on extremely low friction for sellers, trader-level accountability is not a compliance detail. It is a change to the supply model.
The consumer dimension is equally concrete. The products at issue in the May decision included dangerous baby toys and faulty chargers, categories where a defective listing is not a matter of disappointed expectations but of physical injury. The Commission's finding that high-risk categories are flagged but not prioritised in physical checks speaks directly to that exposure. With more than 120 million users in the EU, according to Commission officials, the practical reach of any improvement or any continued failure is measured in a population larger than that of most member states.
There is also a governance signal in the timing. The Commission approved Temu's action plan in October 2026 and issued preliminary findings a month later. That one-month gap is a deliberate message to the wider market: accepting a remediation plan does not suspend the underlying obligation, and a platform cannot bank procedural cooperation as a substitute for results. For the European Board for Digital Services, consulted in parallel, the case is an early test of how coordinated supervision across 27 national regulators handles a marketplace whose sellers sit outside the bloc entirely.
Next Up
Temu now has the right to examine the file and reply in writing, and the company has already said it will do so while disputing the findings. The European Board for Digital Services will be consulted in parallel, after which the Commission decides whether to confirm the preliminary findings and adopt a non-compliance decision. If it does, the file moves to the penalty and remedy stage, where the ceiling is 6 percent of worldwide turnover and the order to remedy the breach becomes the operative instrument. A negotiated resolution remains possible, and Temu's spokesperson has said the company is confident of an amicable outcome that addresses the Commission's remaining concerns.
The other three strands of the October 2024 proceedings remain live: addictive design, recommender systems and researcher access to platform data. None of them has yet produced a decision, and any of them could generate further findings. For Temu, the calendar now holds two tracks at once, a defence of the Article 35 file it has just received and the unresolved questions that the original investigation has not yet answered.
Comments (0)
Log in or sign up to leave a comment.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.