Policy

Italy fines Meta 805 million euros over Android gallery access without consent

Italy's privacy watchdog ordered Meta to switch off a gallery suggestion feature by default and pay 805 million euros for reading Android photo libraries without specific consent.

T
By TechQuire Daily Staff TechQuire Daily Staff
November 15, 2026 / 7 min read

Smartphones have become the most intimate archive most people own, and European privacy law treats the device itself as a protected space rather than an ordinary appliance. The ePrivacy Directive, transposed into Italian law through Article 122 of the Privacy Code, requires free and informed consent before anyone reads the information a handset stores. That principle, rather than the broader data protection machinery built around the GDPR, sits at the centre of a decision issued in Rome on Saturday, November 14, 2026, against the company that operates Facebook across Europe.

The Italian Data Protection Authority, known as the Garante per la protezione dei dati personali, fined Meta Platforms Ireland Limited 805 million euros, or roughly 887 million dollars, after concluding that the Facebook app for Android had reached into the photo galleries of Italian users without obtaining specific consent and without adequately informing them. The authority said the company had accessed photographs, videos and the metadata attached to them.

At issue is a feature the regulator calls Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook, available since 2023. It proposes pictures and clips from a user's own phone gallery as ideas for posts while the person scrolls through the feed. The Garante found that gallery access was requested through a single authorisation valid for the entire app and for several functions with different purposes, and that the notice shown beforehand merely asked users to enable other functions, a phrasing that did not allow a person to understand that gallery suggestions were also being switched on.

The case began in July 2025 with a complaint from the Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti di Bolzano, a consumer protection centre based in Bolzano. What followed was a fact-finding file that the regulator used to justify both the size of the penalty and the remedies it ordered. Meta has rejected the findings, disputes the legal basis and says it will appeal.

Key Facts

Reuters reported on November 14 that the authority fined Meta Platforms 805 million euros, equivalent to 887 million dollars, and gave the company 60 days to disable the gallery feature by default and to seek users' consent separately. The agency said the feature was pre-set as active, meaning that many people never made an explicit choice about it at all. Reuters also reported that the fine is equivalent to about 0.47% of the group's global revenue.

The regulator estimated that around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected. The Guardian reported on November 15 that the penalty is roughly 0.4% of Meta's annual turnover, which reached 201 billion dollars in 2025, for a net profit of 60.5 billion dollars, and that it ranks among the largest sanctions an Italian authority has imposed on a technology company.

BBC News reported on November 14 that the authority took into account the high number of people affected and the fact that the feature was still operating for users who had not updated the app and for those who had already given their consent to the system. The regulator also cited Meta's lack of cooperation during the investigation. In setting the amount, the Garante said it weighed the duration of the infringement and a previous measure it issued in 2019.

The Associated Press reported on November 14 that the fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, the entity that contracts with European users, and that the company had challenged Italy's jurisdiction in favour of the Irish regulator. The Garante rejected that argument, noting that the ePrivacy rules do not provide for a one-stop-shop mechanism of the kind that allocates GDPR cases to a lead authority. The authority also said it reserved the right to assess separately a new feature launched in 2026 that allows content from users' galleries to be processed in the cloud.

Meta's response was blunt. A spokesperson said the company would appeal, strongly disagreeing with the authority's assessment of the facts, its application of the law and what it called the disproportionate level of the fine. The company described the function as a simple feature that helps people share photos and videos on Facebook, adding that users must grant permission on their device before it can operate and can change that permission at any time in their settings.

Analysis

The legal heart of the case is not the volume of data involved but the quality of the consent obtained. The Garante's objection is structural: one permission covering many purposes, presented behind a generic prompt, cannot amount to specific consent for gallery suggestions, because a reasonable user cannot tell from the notice that the gallery is being read at all. What this really means is that Italy has effectively declared the bundled permission prompt, in which one authorisation serves several functions, unlawful when it obscures a purpose that touches the private storage of a device.

That framing explains why the authority reached for Article 122 of the Privacy Code rather than relying on the GDPR alone. The ePrivacy provision, as the regulator described it, protects the smartphone as part of a person's private sphere, requiring free and informed consent for any access to that information. The Garante used that rule to sidestep the jurisdictional argument that would ordinarily send a case about an Irish-established company to the Irish Data Protection Commission. The rejection of Meta's competence objection matters beyond this single file, because it demonstrates that national regulators can act on device-level access rules without waiting for a lead authority to move first.

The penalty also carries a message about conduct during an inquiry. The regulator explicitly counted Meta's lack of cooperation and the duration of the infringement, alongside the sheer number of affected users, and it pointed out that the practice continued for people who had not updated the app. A fine calibrated to about 0.47% of global revenue is not designed to be existential, but it is large enough to be felt, and it sits close to the top of the range Italian authorities have applied to technology companies.

There is a wider context that the authority deliberately left open. The investigation did not cover the possible use of gallery content to train artificial intelligence models, which Meta denies, and the regulator said it reserved the right to examine a 2026 feature that processes gallery content in the cloud. The bigger picture here is that Rome has separated the consent question from the AI question, keeping a second and potentially more consequential dispute in reserve while establishing the principle that device access needs its own explicit permission.

Why It Matters

For users, the decision is a reminder that a permission granted once on a phone can travel much further than the moment of the tap suggests. A single authorisation issued through the device can be consumed by several features inside an app, and the notice shown then is often the only chance to understand the trade. The Garante's order requires the feature to be off by default within 60 days and to be paired with a separate, specific consent request, changing the default from opt out to opt in for Italian users.

For the industry, the case adds a European precedent about how consent must be granular when a feature reads local storage. Companies that rely on one broad permission to power several functions now face a clearer risk that a national authority will treat the arrangement as a failure to limit purpose. The size of the penalty, and the fact that it was issued by a national regulator under an ePrivacy rule rather than through the GDPR's cooperation mechanism, gives other authorities a template they can copy without needing agreement from a lead supervisor.

For Meta, the immediate cost is financial but the precedent is operational. The company is already contesting a 25 billion dollar order from a judge in the US state of New Mexico, issued in late October, over how it handled user data. Adding a European consent ruling on device access, at a moment when a new 2026 feature allows gallery content to be processed in the cloud, means the compliance question is unlikely to disappear on appeal.

Next Up

Meta has 60 days from the notification to switch the gallery feature off by default and to obtain separate, specific consent, and it has said it will appeal. The appeal will test both the substance of the consent finding and the authority's decision to apply Italian ePrivacy rules to an Irish-established company. Separately, the Garante has signalled that it may open a fresh assessment of the 2026 cloud processing feature, which could extend the argument from reading a gallery to moving its contents off the device entirely.

The other open thread is artificial intelligence. The regulator stated that this proceeding did not address whether gallery content was used to train models, a use Meta denies, leaving that question for a future case. The next phase will show whether Italy's reading of device-level consent survives review, and whether other European regulators decide to follow the same path.

Tagged

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.