Hardware

US Judge Lets DRAM Supply Conspiracy Case Against Samsung, SK hynix and Micron Proceed

A California federal court has allowed 17 buyers to pursue claims that the three biggest memory makers starved the market of conventional DRAM while steering capacity to AI chips.

T
By TechQuire Daily Staff TechQuire Daily Staff
November 16, 2026 / 7 min read

A federal judge in California has refused to dismiss a proposed class action accusing the world's three largest memory chipmakers of conspiring to restrain supply of conventional DRAM, the commodity memory used in laptops, phones and servers. In an order dated November 14, US District Judge Noël Wise of the Northern District of California denied in full the joint motion to dismiss in Garciaguirre v. Samsung Electronics, case number 5:26-cv-06345. The decision lets 17 consumers and small businesses from five states pursue claims against Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Micron Technology.

The dispute lands in the middle of an unusual period for memory. High bandwidth memory, or HBM, has absorbed wafer capacity as AI accelerators consume ever larger amounts of silicon, and buyers of ordinary DDR5 modules have faced steep increases in a component that was long treated as a commodity. The complaint, filed on June 25, 2026, alleges that the shortage was not merely the result of a demand surge but of coordinated choices by three companies that the plaintiffs say controlled more than 91 percent of global DRAM revenue.

The defendants asked the court to end the case before discovery, arguing in part that it repeated earlier antitrust litigation against the industry. Judge Wise rejected that position, concluding that the allegations, accepted as true for purposes of the motion, plausibly describe an agreement under Section 1 of the Sherman Act. Her order stresses that this is a pleading stage decision and that no liability has been found.

The distinction matters because motions to dismiss test the sufficiency of a complaint, not the truth of its claims. At this stage the plaintiffs need only clear a plausibility threshold, and the court must draw reasonable inferences in their favor. The ruling therefore says more about the strength of the narrative the buyers have assembled than about what discovery will eventually show.

Key Facts

LitNews reported on November 14 that the plaintiffs are 17 individuals and small businesses from five states who filed suit on June 25, 2026, and that the case concerns conventional DRAM, described in the complaint as standardized memory built to industry specifications and sold for ordinary purposes, including DDR5 modules. The complaint alleges that Samsung, SK hynix and Micron controlled more than 91 percent of global DRAM revenue as of the third quarter of 2025, with SK hynix at 33.2 percent, Samsung at 32.6 percent and Micron at 25.7 percent. Those figures are allegations, not judicial findings.

The order's treatment of timing is central. The plaintiffs allege that SK hynix and Micron announced production cuts within three weeks of each other, on October 26, 2022 and November 16, 2022, and that Samsung followed on April 7, 2023. Judge Wise wrote that the roughly one quarter lag is not such an unreasonably long delay that it defeats an allegation of parallel conduct on a motion to dismiss, and she cited Jones v. Micron Technology as precedent for parallel conduct in which one maker cut output in one quarter and rivals followed in the next.

On capacity, the complaint alleges that the defendants began shifting capacity toward HBM, which requires approximately three to four times the silicon wafer area per gigabyte compared with conventional DDR5 DRAM. By the third quarter of 2025, conventional DRAM prices had risen 171.8 percent in one year, and the complaint alleges a 697 percent increase over 18 months. LitNews reported on November 14 that the complaint also asserts that not one of the three defendants expanded or announced plans to meaningfully expand commodity DRAM production capacity.

Judge Wise found that a bare pivot to HBM might not by itself support an inference of conspiracy, given the technology's higher profitability, but that related conduct tips the factor over the edge. The court pointed to long-term HBM contracts, reported refusals by Samsung and SK hynix to sign long-term agreements with major conventional DRAM customers, and Micron's December 3, 2025 decision to close Crucial, its consumer brand of roughly three decades. It also noted that all three companies announced DDR4 phase-outs within the same quarter while DDR4 remained widely used, and that near-identical customer vetting questions introduced in January 2026 strongly support a plausible inference of conspiracy.

The court gave no weight to investor statements about supply discipline, to executive meetings at trade conferences, or to the oligopolistic structure of the market. It did consider the industry's earlier cartel history from 1998 to 2002, when Samsung paid a $300 million fine and Hynix paid $185 million while Micron received immunity. Answering Judge Posner's observation that competitors watch each other like hawks, Wise wrote that the allegations are more akin to hawks flying in formation, an activity that hawks ordinarily do not do. The order sets answers for December 7, 2026 and resets the initial case management conference to January 12, 2027 at 9:00 a.m.

Analysis

What this really means is that the buyers have cleared the threshold that kills most antitrust class actions before they reach documents or depositions. A denial of a motion to dismiss is not a verdict, and the defendants retain strong defenses, including the argument that the price increases reflected genuine AI demand rather than coordination.

The spine of the ruling is timing. Three companies cut output within a span of months, and the court treated the lag between the first two announcements and Samsung's later move as consistent with, rather than fatal to, an inference of coordination. The hawks flying in formation line does real work here. It rejects the idea that conscious parallelism is all the plaintiffs have pleaded and accepts that the complaint describes something closer to a shared plan. The reference to Jones v. Micron Technology also matters because it gives the plaintiffs a template that a court has accepted before.

The HBM analysis is more nuanced. The court accepted that a shift to a more profitable product is not automatically suspicious, which is a real point for the defense. It then found that the surrounding conduct, including long-term HBM contracts, refusals to sign long-term conventional DRAM deals and the Crucial shutdown, made the pivot harder to explain as an independent business decision. The January 2026 customer vetting questions appear to have been especially important because they came after the HBM shift, undermining the claim that AI demand alone explains the pattern.

The limits of the ruling are worth stating plainly. Judge Wise discounted the oligopoly structure, statements about capital discipline and meetings at trade conferences, which means the plaintiffs cannot rely on market concentration alone as discovery proceeds. They will need evidence of communications or decisions that show coordination. Tom's Hardware reported on November 15 that the court rejected the defense argument that the action was merely a rerun of the same antitrust case filed against the industry in 2018, because the plaintiffs established new evidence suggesting collusion. That finding keeps the case alive but does not guarantee it survives summary judgment.

Why It Matters

For anyone buying PCs, phones or servers, the case connects a legal theory to a pricing experience. The complaint's central claim is that conventional DRAM, the least glamorous part of the memory stack, became scarce and expensive because capacity was steered toward HBM. If that account holds up, device makers and consumers bore costs that a jury could find were the product of unlawful choices.

TrendForce reported on November 16 that discovery could force Samsung, SK hynix and Micron to hand over internal emails, management meeting records, customer allocation criteria and capacity investment documents. That prospect gives PC, smartphone and server makers leverage to demand long-term supply agreements, while the memory makers face added legal risk whenever they adjust output or investment plans. TrendForce also noted that immediate financial impact is likely to be limited because US antitrust cases can take years.

The precedent extends beyond this docket. A court has now accepted that parallel capacity decisions, a product mix shift and identical customer screening practices can plausibly support a Section 1 claim in the memory market. Even if the plaintiffs ultimately lose, the ruling signals that the line between aggressive capacity management and unlawful coordination will be litigated in front of a jury unless the parties settle or the claims are narrowed.

Next Up

Defendants must answer by December 7, 2026, and the initial case management conference is set for January 12, 2027 at 9:00 a.m., where the parties will address the scope of discovery and the schedule for the case. The court also granted an unopposed motion to extend early deadlines after resetting the argument schedule by roughly three weeks.

The next real test will be whether the plaintiffs can turn plausible allegations into evidence. Class certification, summary judgment and any settlement talks are still ahead, and the order itself makes clear that nothing has been proven. For now the case proceeds, and the memory market's pricing and capacity decisions will be examined under a legal microscope.

Tagged

Comments (0)

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.